| 1 | Britt Baker | April Sera | 12/10/2016 | Elizabeth, PA | **Wins a four-way elimination match also involving Marti Belle and Sonya Strong to win the title
|
| 2 | LuFisto | Britt Baker | 07/22/2017 | Elizabeth, PA | |
| 3 | Britt Baker | LuFisto | 10/14/2017 | Elizabeth, PA | **Wins a single-fall three-way also involving Ray Lyn
|
| 4 | Katie Arquette | Britt Baker | 11/10/2018 | Elizabeth, PA | |
| 5 | Madison Rayne | Katie Arquette | 02/16/2019 | Elizabeth, PA | |
| 6 | Katie Arquette | Madison Rayne | 03/16/2019 | Elizabeth, PA | |
| 7 | Ray Lyn | Katie Arquette | 8/10/2019 | Elizabeth, PA | |
| 8 | Katie Arquette | Ray Lyn | 11/08/2020 | Elizabeth, PA | |
| 9 | Ella Shae | Katie Arquette | 12/4/2021 | Elizabeth, PA | |
| 10 | Ashley D'Amboise | Ella Shae | 1/22/2022 | Elizabeth, PA | |
| 11 | Ray Lyn | Ashley D'Amboise | 12/4/2022 | Elizabeth, PA | |
| 12 | Holidead | Ray Lyn | 6/3/2023 | Elizabeth, PA | |
| 13 | Katie Arquette | Holidead | 12/2/2023 | Elizabeth, PA | |
| 14 | Mila Moore | Lexus Synn | 11/2/2024 | Elizabeth, PA | **Katie Arquette had to vacate the title due to injury |
