| Champion | Defeated | Date | Location | Notes | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Scottie Gash & J-Ru | Sexual Harassment | 02/16/2002 | Uniontown, PA | **Wins match for the vacant title |
| 2 | Sexual Harassment (JT Rodgers & Eric Xtasy) | Scottie Gash | 03/23/2002 | Uniontown, PA | **J-Ru was injured. This was a handicap match. |
| 3 | Scottie Gash & Jim Duggan | Sexual Harassment | 05/10/2002 | White Oak, PA | |
| 4 | Sexual Harassment (JT Rodgers & Eric Xtasy) | Scottie Gash & Jim Duggan | 06/06/2002 | Penn Hills, PA | |
| 5 | The Devil's Advocates (Devil Bhudakahn, Glenn Spectre, & Jake Garrett) | Sexual Harassment | 12/27/2002 | West Mifflin, PA | **Because Jake Garrett scored the pinfall in this handicap match, all three men were allowed to defend the titles. |
| 6 | Sexual Harassment (JT Rodgers & Eric Xtasy) | The Devil's Advocates | 02/22/2003 | Butler, PA | **Was a six-man tag, with Sabu on Sexual Harassment's team |
| 7 | The Devil's Advocates (Devil Bhudakahn & Glenn Spectre) | Troy Lords & JT Rodgers | 04/12/2003 | Munhall, PA | **Lords substituted for the injured Eric Xtasy |
| 8 | Sexual Harassment (JT Rodgers & Troy Lords) | The Devil's Advocates | 05/10/2003 | White Oak, PA | |
| 9 | The Devil's Advocates | Sexual Harassment | 06/28/2003 | Prospect, PA | |
| 10 | Youthanazia (Josh Prohibition & M-Dogg Matt Cross) | The Devil's Advocates | 11/01/2003 | West MIfflin, PA | |
| 11 | Southern Comfort | Youthanazia | 05/08/2004 | West Mifflin, PA | |
| 12 | The Midnight Express (Dennis Condrey & Bobby Eaton) | Southern Comfort | 12/11/2004 | Wilmerding, PA | |
| 13 | The Unholy Alliance (HENTAI & Sebastian Dark) | The Midnight Express | 04/30/2005 | Uniontown, PA | |
| 14 | Southern Comfort (Tracy Smothers & Chris Hamrick) | The Unholy Alliance | 08/26/2005 | McKeesport, PA | |
| 15 | The Gambino Brothers (Marshall Gambino & Mickey Gambino) | Chris Hamrick & Jason Cage | 11/27/2005 | McKeesport, PA | **Cage substituted for the injured Tracy Smothers |
| 16 | The Burning River Brigade (Josh Prohibition & M-Dogg Matt Cross) | VACANT | 05/13/2006 | Elizabeth, PA | |
| 17 | The Cleveland Mafia (J-Rocc & Raymond Rowe) | The Burning River Brigade | 06/06/2006 | Elizabeth, PA | **Wins a three-way match also including The Gambino Brothers |
| 18 | The Gambino Brothers (Marshall Gambino & Mickey Gambino) | The Cleveland Mafia | 10/14/2006 | Elizabeth, PA | |
| 19 | BabyFace Fire (Shiima XIon & Jason Gory) | VACANT | 12/09/2006) | Elizabeth, PA | **Wins a four-way match also including The Cleveland Mafia and Sexual Harassment |
| 20 | The Gambino Brothers (Marshall Gambino & Mickey Gambino) | BabyFace Fire | 03/23/2007 | Elizabeth, PA | |
| 21 | Michael Facade & Johnny Gargano | The Cleveland Mafia | 05/11/2007 | McKeesport, PA | **Wins a gauntlet match also including Sexual Harassment, The Heartbreakers, and the Hollywood Balds |
| 22 | The Gambino Brothers (Marshall Gambino & Mickey Gambino) | Michael Facade & Johnny Gargano | 07/07/2007 | Elizabeth, PA | |
| 23 | BabyFace FIre (Shiima Xion & Jason Gory) | VACANT | 12/08/2007 | Elizabeth, PA | |
| 24 | Sexual Harassment (Justin Idol & Eric Xtasy) | BabyFace Fire | 06/07/2008 | Elizabeth, PA | |
| 25 | The Gambino Brothers (Marshall Gambino & Mickey Gambino) | Sexual Harassment | 10/26/2008 | Cheswick, PA | **Wins a four-way match also including the New Cleveland Mafia and The Best Around |
| 26 | Sexual Harassment (Justin Idol & Eric Xtasy) | VACANT | 12/20/2008 | Elizabeth, PA | **Wins a three-way match also including Irish Airborne |
| 27 | Irish Airborne (Jake Crist & Dave Crist) | Sexual Harassment | 01/24/2009 | Elizabeth, PA | |
| 28 | Flippin' Ain't Easy (Facade & Gory) | Irish Airborne | 05/08/2010 | Elizabeth, PA | |
| 29 | The Founding Fathers (Dennis Gregory & Jimmy Vega$) | Flippin' Ain't Easy | 05/27/2011 | Elizabeth, PA | |
| 30 | The One Nighters (Bobby Beverly & Nicki Valentino) | The Founding Fathers, The Gambino Brothers, Aeroform | 12/10/2011 | Elizabeth, PA | **Was a four-way scramble match for the vacant titles |
| 31 | The Founding Fathers (Dennis Gregory, Jimmy Vega$, & Super Hentai) | The One Nighters | 08/25/2012 | Elizabeth, PA | |
| 32 | Colin Delaney & Keith Haught | The Founding Fathers | 05/09/2013 | Elizabeth, PA | |
| 33 | Team Big League (Jimmy Nutts & Joseph Brooks) | Colin Delaney & Keith Haught | 08/25/2013 | Elizabeth, PA | **Was a three-way match also involving W.A.R. |
| 34 | The Sexy Talented Dudes (Chest Flexor & Brian McDowell) | Team Big League | 12/14/2013 | Elizabeth, PA | **Was a four-way elimination match also involving Marshall Gambino & Bronco McBride, and Colin Delaney & Keith Haught |
| 35 | The Hollywood Balds (Jimmy DeMarco & Vendetta) | Chest Flexor & Bronco McBride | 10/18/2014 | Elizabeth, PA | **Bronco McBride was substituting for a missing Brian McDowell |
| 36 | VIP Joe Rosa & Jimmy Vega$ | Darin Dinero & Joseph Brooks | 01/24/2015 | Elizabeth, PA | **The Hollywood Balds vacated the titles after Jimmy DeMarco & Chuck Roberts sold the company **Both teams were chosen by the "Reset Button" |
| 37 | Bearded For Your Pleasure (Jock Samson & Bryan Castle) | Team VIP, The Founding Fathers | 05/09/2015 | Elizabeth, PA | **Rosa & Vega$ refused to defend the titles together, so a three-way dance was made with both men's teams included |
| 38 | The Fraternity (Channing Decker & Trent Gibson) | Bearded For Your Pleasure | 12/12/2015 | Elizabeth, PA | **Was a four-way scramble also involving the Gambino Brothers and the Founding Fathers |
| 39 | Remy Lavey & Keith Haught | The Fraternity | 04/09/2016 | Meadville, PA | |
| 40 | The Fraternity (Channing Decker & Trent Gibson) | Remy Lavey & Keith Haught | 04/23/2016 | Clearfield, PA | |
| 41 | Locked & Loaded (Duke Davis & Ganon Jones, Jr.) | The Fraternity | 08/19/2017 | Elizabeth, PA | |
| 42 | The Fraternity (Channing Decker & Trent Gibson) | Locked & Loaded | 12/09/2017 | Elizabeth, PA | |
| 43 | Team LaBar (Chris LeRusso & Dennis Jackson) | 06/09/2018 | Elizabeth, PA | **LeRusso & Jackson were awarded the titles by Justin Labar following inactivity by The Fraternity |
|
| 44 | Team Storm (Jaxon Argos & RC Dupree) | Chris LeRusso & Bulk Nasty | 08/11/2018 | Elizabeth, PA | **Was a one-fall three-way also involving The Mane Event **Bulk Nasty was substituting for Dennis Jackson |
| 45 | The Mane Event (Duke Davis & Ganon Jones, Jr.) | Team Storm | 12/08/2018 | Elizabeth, PA | |
| 46 | The Regulators (Jock Samson & Chris Lerusso) | The Mane Event | 07/13/2019 | Elizabeth, PA | |
| 47 | The Mane Event (Duke Davis & Ganon Jones, Jr.) | The Regulators | 09/13/2019 | Wheeling, WV | |
| 48 | The North (Ethan Page & Josh Alexander) | The Mane Event | 11/02/2019 | Elizabeth, PA | **This was a Winner Takes All match where the Impact Tag Team Championships were also on the line |
| 49 | The Regulators (Chris Lerusso & Jock Samson) | The North | 12/07/2019 | Elizabeth, PA | |
| 50 | Steak and Eggs (Bulk Nasty and Zander Gabriel aka Bulk Nasty and Bulk Nasty) | The Regulators (Chris Lerusso & Jock Samson) | 01/18/2020 | Elizabeth, PA | |
| 51 | Money Shot (Elijah Dean & Zach Nystrom) | Steak'n'Eggs (Bulk Nasty & Zander Gabriel) | 9/19/2020 | Brownsville, PA | |
| 52 | TME (Duke Davis & Ganon Jones, Jr.) | Money Shot (Elijah Dean & Zach Nystrom) | 12/4/2021 | Elizabeth, PA | **This was a TLC Triple Threat with Hardcore Hammer Time. |
| 53 | The Hardy Boyz (Matt and Jeff Hardy) | TME (Duke Davis & Ganon Jones, Jr.) | 4/30/2022 | Rostraver, PA | |
| 54 | Lebanon Don Joey Moses & Tito Oric (Disputed) | The Hardy Boyz | 6/18/2022 | Elizabeth, PA | *The Lebanon Don claims to have purchased the titles from the Hardys. |
| 55 | TME (Duke Davis & Ganon Jones Jr.) | Jaxon Argos and Preston Everest | 7/31/2022 | Rostraver, PA | *Fatal 4 way match for the IWC Tag Team Championships The Culmination and Good Budz were also in the match. |
| 56 | Brotherly Love (Ricky Dawkins and Kliff Klepto) | Lebanon Don and Tito Oric | 12/4/2022 | Elizabeth, PA | **3 Way Tag Match, Also in the match was TME (Duke Davis & Ganon Jones Jr.) |
| 57 | TME (Duke Davis & Ganon Jones Jr.) | The Culmination | 3/25/2023 | Elizabeth, PA | **3 Way Tag Match, Also in the match was Brotherly Love (Ricky Dawkins and Kliff Klepto) |
| 58 | Lebanon Don and Tito Oric | Chase Gold and Mambo Italiano | 4/29/2023 | Rostraver, PA | **4 Way Tag Match, Also in the match was Brotherly Love (Ricky Dawkins and Kliff Klepto), Anthony Young and Alexander Apollo. Titles were surrendered by Ganon Jones Jr due to TME temporarily disbanding. |
