1 | Shirley Doe | Mad Mike | 03/17/2001 | McKees Rocks, PA | **Wins a falls-count-anywhere battle royal also involving JT Rogers, Eric Xtasy, Kid Cupid, White Trash Hero, J-Ru, Dale Price, Scottie Gash, Amnesiac, and Jake Garrett
|
2 | Kid Sensation | Shirley Doe | 11/10/2001 | Monroeville, PA | |
3 | Shirley Doe | Kid Sensation | 01/19/2002 | Uniontown, PA | |
4 | Boomer Payne | Shirley Doe | 03/02/2002 | West Mifflin, PA | **The title is retired after Boomer Payne leaves IWC and the Pittsburgh area following this event
|
5 | Jimmy Vega$ | Marshall Gambino, Bulk Nasty, Nathan Aulridge, Jami Jameson | 10/27/2017 | Wheeling, WV | *Title is reinstated in 2017. Match was for the vacant title.
|
6 | Bulk Nasty | Jimmy Vega$ | 11/04/2017 | Clearfield, PA | *Was a four-way also involving Colby Redd and Shane InYaFace
|
7 | Gillberg | Bulk Nasty | 02/17/2017 | Elizabeth, PA | |
8 | James Ellsworth | Gillberg | 03/17/2017 | Elizabeth, PA | |
9 | VACANT | James Ellsworth | 03/17/2017 | Elizabeth, PA | |
10 | Chest Flexor | VACANT | 08/11/2018 | Elizabeth, PA | |
11 | RC Dupree | Chest Flexor | 02/16/2019 | Elizabeth, PA | *Was a six-way also involving Jami Jameson, Philip Archer, Stevie Lebell, and Jason Tyler |
12 | Hardcore Hooven | RC Dupree | 10/5/2019 | Elizabeth, PA | |
13 | Mambo Italiano | Hardcore Hooven | 2/22/2020 | Elizabeth, PA | *Shane Douglas as guest referee requested a stipulation be added to make this an extreme rules match |
14 | RC Dupree | Mambo Italiano | 3/14/2020 | Elizabeth, PA | |
15 | Tito Oric | RC Dupree | 12/5/2020 | Elizabeth, PA | *IWC's 1st ever Casket Match |
16 | Lebanon Don Joey Moses | ** | 12/5/2020 | Elizabeth, PA | **After Tito Oric defeated RC Dupree, Lebanon Don purchased the High Stakes Title from him for $100,000 |
17 | Alexander Apollo | Lebanon Don Joey Moses | 8/14/2021 | Elizabeth, PA | |
18 | Spencer Slade | Alexander Apollo | 12/4/2022 | Elizabeth, PA | |
19 | Sam Handeman | Spencer Slade | 12/2/2023 | Elizabeth, PA | **Eliminated Spencer Slade from the Pittsburgh Classic Battle Royal where Spencer put the title on the line. |