| Champion | Defeated | Date | Location | Notes | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Super Hentai | Christopher Daniels | 03/22/2002 | Monroeville, PA | **Wins the Super Indy Tournament |
| 2 | AJ Styles | Super Hentai | 03/14/2003 | Penn Hills, PA | |
| 3 | Colt Cabana | Matt Stryker | 05/10/2003 | White Oak, PA | **Wins the Super Indy II Tournament |
| 4 | AJ Styles | Colt Cabana | 03/20/2004 | West Mifflin, PA | |
| 5 | Chris Sabin | Alex Shelley | 05/08/2004 | West Mifflin, PA | **Wins the Super Indy III Tournament **Forced to vacate the title due to injury |
| 6 | Sterling James Keenan | Petey Williams | 12/11/2004 | Wilmerding, PA | **Wins a four-way match also involving Josh Prohibition and John McChesney to win the vacant title |
| 7 | John McChesney | Low Ki | 04/29/2005 | McKeesport, PA | **Wins the Super Indy IV Tournament |
| 8 | Sterling James Keenan | John McChesney | 08/20/2005 | Morristown, NJ | **Change occurred during ROH's Do Or Die V event |
| 9 | John McChesney | Sterling James Keenan | 08/26/2005 | McKeesport, PA | |
| 10 | Low Ki | John McChesney | 03/18/2006 | Elizabeth, PA | |
| 11 | Delirious | Troy Lords | 04/15/2006 | Elizabeth, PA | **Wins the Super Indy V Tournament |
| 12 | John McChesney | Delirious | 11/11/2006 | Elizabeth, PA | |
| 13 | Troy Lords | John McChesney | 01/19/2007 | Elizabeth, PA | |
| 14 | Jason Gory | Troy Lords | 05/11/2007 | McKeesport, PA | **Wins a four-way match also involving John McChesney and Eric Young |
| 15 | Larry Sweeney | Shiima Xion | 05/11/2007 | McKeesport, PA | **Wins the Super Indy VI Tournament |
| 16 | John McChesney | Larry Sweeney | 07/07/2007 | Elizabeth, PA | |
| 17 | Larry Sweeney | John McChesney | 01/19/2008 | Elizabeth, PA | |
| 18 | Jerry Lynn | Larry Sweeney | 05/17/2008 | Elizabeth, PA | **Lynn wins the Super Indy VII Tournament in April, but refuses the title until he can pin then-champ Sweeney. This match was to prove the undisputed champion. |
| 19 | Johnny Gargano | Jerry Lynn | 10/11/2008 | Elizabeth, PA | **Forced to vacate the title due to injury |
| 20 | Delirious | Jason Gory | 10/26/2008 | Cheswick, PA | **Wins a four-way match also including Super Hentai and Larry Sweeney to win the vacant title |
| 21 | Super Hentai | Justin Idol | 05/16/2009 | Elizabeth, PA | **Wins the Super Indy VIII Tournament |
| 22 | Shiima Xion | Johnny Gargano | 05/08/2010 | Elizabeth, PA | **Wins the Super Indy IX Tournament **Was a three-way elimination match also including Azrieal |
| 23 | Super Hentai | Shiima Xion | 01/29/2011 | Elizabeth, PA | |
| 24 | Matthew Justice | Super Hentai | 03/19/2011 | Elizabeth, PA | **Was a three-way match also including Shiima Xion |
| 25 | Super Hentai | Matthew Justice | 04/16/2011 | Franklin, PA | |
| 26 | Egotistico Fantastico | El Generico | 06/18/2011 | Elizabeth, PA | **Wins the Super Indy X Tournament **Was a three-way elimination match also including Super Hentai |
| 27 | Facade | Logan Shulo, Hallowicked, M-Dogg Matt Cross | 12/10/2011 | Elizabeth, PA | **Four-Way ladder match for vacated title |
| 28 | Sami Callihan | Facade | 06/23/2012 | Elizabeth, PA | **Wins the Super Indy XI Tournament |
| 29 | Facade | Sami Callihan | 10/20/2012 | Elizabeth, PA | **Was a one-fall three-way match also involving Rich Swann |
| 30 | Logan Shulo | Sami Callihan | 12/15/2012 | Elizabeth, PA | **Facade was forced to surrender the title due to injury. This was a match to determine both IWC World Heavyweight Champion and IWC Super Indy Champion. |
| 31 | Anthony Nese | Logan Shulo | 01/26/2013 | Elizabeth, PA | |
| 32 | Facade | Anthony Nese | 06/15/2013 | Elizabeth, PA | **Wins the Super Indy XII Tournament **Was a three-way eliminiation match also including Gory |
| 33 | Shiima Xion | Facade | 10/19/2013 | Elizabeth, PA | |
| 34 | RJ City | Shiima Xion | 12/14/2013 | Elizabeth, PA | |
| 35 | Andrew Palace | RJ City | 10/18/2014 | Elizabeth, PA | |
| 36 | Dylan Bostic | Alex Daniels | 06/13/2015 | Elizabeth, PA | **Wins the Super Indy XIV Tournament **Was a three-way eliminiation match also including Raymond Rowe |
| 37 | Andrew Palace | Dylan Bostic | 12/12/2015 | Elizabeth, PA | |
| 38 | Josh Alexander | Jonathan Gresham | 06/11/2016 | Elizabeth, PA | **Wins the Super Indy 15 Tournament **Vacated the title due to inability to defend it |
| 39 | Chis LeRusso | Facade | 10/15/2016 | Elizabeth, PA | **Match for the vacant title |
| 40 | John McChesney | Chris LeRusso | 04/08/2017 | Meadville, PA | |
| 41 | Chris LeRusso | John McChesney | 05/13/2017 | Elizabeth, PA | |
| 42 | Adam Cole | Jonathan Gresham | 06/10/2017 | Elizabeth, PA | **Wins the Super Indy 16 Tournament |
| 43 | John McChesney | Adam Cole | 07/22/2017 | Elizabeth, PA | **McChesney was forced to vacate the title due to a shoulder injury |
| 44 | Gory | Anthony Henry, Suge D, Joey Janela | 08/19/2017 | Elizabeth, PA | *Was a single-fall four-way to determine a new champion |
| 45 | Jonathan Gresham | David Starr | 06/08/2018 | Elizabeth, PA | **Wins the Super Indy 17 Tournament |
| 46 | John McChesney | Jonathan Gresham | 01/19/2019 | Elizabeth, PA | |
| 47 | Wardlow | John McChesney | 03/16/2019 | Elizabeth, PA | **Was a Champion Vs. Champion Match |
| 48 | Josh Alexander | Wardlow | 8/10/2019 | Elizabeth, PA | |
| 49 | Johnny Patch | Josh Alexander | 10/5/2019 | Elizabeth, PA | |
| 50 | Brian Pillman, Jr | Lee Moriarty | 9/12/2020 | Washington, PA | **Wins the Super Indy 19 Tournament. |
| 51 | Bill Collier | Brian Pillman, Jr | 2/20/2021 | Elizabeth, PA | |
| 52 | Matthew Justice | Bill Collier | 7/17/2021 | Elizabeth, PA | |
| 53 | Bill Collier | Matthew Justice | 8/14/2021 | Elizabeth, PA | |
| 54 | Cole Karter | Anthony Greene | 10/16/2021 | Elizabeth, PA | **Wins the Super Indy 20 Tournament |
| 55 | Derek Dillinger | Anthony Young | 1/22/2022 | Elizabeth, PA | **Cole Karter was signed by WWE and was forced to vacate the title which was then competed for in a fatal 4 way by Derek Dillinger, Anthony Young, Jaxon Argos, and Andrew Palace |
| 56 | Cole Karter | Derek Dillinger | 10/8/2022 | Elizabeth, PA | **Wins the Super Indy 21 Tournament |
| 57 | Jock Samson | Cole Karter | 6/3/2023 | Elizabeth, PA | |
| 58 | Vacant | Jock Samson | 7/9/2023 | Elizabeth, PA | **Jock relinquished the Super Indy title, trading it for a match against Justin Plummer. |
| 59 | Duke Davis | Vacant | 10/7/2023 | Elizabeth, PA | ** Wins the Super Indy 22 Tournament |
| 60 | Ganon Jones Jr | Duke Davis | 11/4/2023 | Elizabeth, PA | |
| 61 | Anthony Catena | Ganon Jones Jr | 11/4/2023 | Elizabeth, PA | **Following Ganon and Dukes match, Justin Plummer calls an impromptu title match for Anthony Catena. |
| 62 | Ganon Jones Jr | Anthony Catena | 12/2/2023 | Elizabeth, PA | **Defeated Anthony Catena in a Lumberjack Match |
| 63 | Sam Holloway | Ganon Jones Jr | 10/5/2024 | Elizabeth, PA | ** Wins the Super Indy 23 Tournament |
